This week we discussed an important question. We were
asked if it is more important to know/do math, or to understand it. As much as
we want our students to do math, as it is required, it is more important that
our students understand what they are doing. Often times, students will
memorize information, and only retain it for as long as they need it, like a
test for instance. However, this is not what we should strive for. It is much
more beneficial for students to understand what they are doing, in order to
retain in within their long-term memory, which will allow students to come back
to their learning at any point in the future. How do we go about doing this
though? How do we truly get our students to understand
math? Simply put, we have them practice, practice, practice.
As educators, we need to differentiate the
instruction in all subjects. One way to do this is through visual aids. Regardless
of what a student’s learning style is, visual aids can be beneficial to all students in math class. If you are
working through a math problem, odds are it will be quicker and easier to solve
if you have the problem right in front of you to work with. For instance, when
we were asked to count to 1000 on our fingers starting at the thumb, on one
hand, we had to conclude what finger we would finish on. Rather than students
counting to 1000, there are ways you could come up with to speed up the process.
For instance, I drew my hand on a sheet of paper. I noticed that my pointer
finger and my ring finger were always even numbers. Therefore, every time I
went up another 10, I wrote that number above the finger it landed on. Once I
got to 20, I kept jumping back and forth between the two fingers until I got to
100. When I found out what finger 100 landed on, I knew that would be the same
finger that 1000 landed on. As a result, 1000 fell on my ring finger. This is a
visual of what it would look like:
Einar
Jorgen Haraldseid. (October 4, 2006). My hand. Retrieved from: https://www.flickr.com/photos/ejh/260959129/in/photolist-p4u4k-fZL6AG-fn8ZQK-DkL-hu399v-2gmPu-cftf7w-dcxmXb-99sLpa-4ji5Lv-5uh8Jv-aRzMCi-2T6KoD-eWKQtL-HmGB7-NoNmb-bqWDkG-84WcqY-oPgLGj-prRbCC-hu1MSi-hu1Pmk-5XRxkZ-8QyBGF-an69JF-djYDXd-34WfVK-62w2QS-5XRHPr-cvUW9h-ciHSTy-bcsP8X-hu1PKM-rnpSoc-d7hvry-5XW1e3-e1GnbW-ehTDCD-5wjKQt-34km4-eWgczG-5uh41F-2gny7-eW3yMX-4CdoFR-98ALqu-9VV5yq-5XS6bF-5XSgyn-4AcQZm
Lastly, an important thing to remember is that when
asking any question, it has to make sense. For instance, one of the questions
that students were asked was about a shepherd having 125 sheep and 5 dogs in a
flock, how old is the shepherd? As educators, we know this question does not
make sense because there is no way a student can find out the shepherd’s age
based on this question. One proper way to word this question could be:
At 20 years old, a shepherd inherits 25 sheep and 1
dog for his flock. Every 2 years, the shepherd adds 25 more sheep and 1 more
dog to the flock. How old will the shepherd be when his flock has 125 sheep and
5 dogs?
This question makes much more sense because it gives
students enough information to do the math to solve the problem. This is just
an example that demonstrates how a math problem must make sense so that
students can solve it. I give credit to the students that still attempted to
solve the problem because you could see where their thought process was.
To summarize, I would hope that you take three
things from this post:
1. Make
sure your students UNDERSTAND the math
2. Visual
aids in mathematics are beneficial for ALL students, regardless of their
learning style
3. If you ask student to solve a math question, make sure the question makes sense!
Thanks for reading!

Hey Jamie,
ReplyDeleteFirst off, I love the way your blog looks. Purple is my favourite colour so seeing this page makes me happy. Next, I like the way you modelled in your blog post they way you might explain a problem's solution when you outlined how you approached the Finger Counting problem. You explained it with words and then pictures and if this was face-to-face I'm sure you would have showed it on your own fingers or had a student demonstrate.
It's important to try as many different ways of explaining a problem as possible because even if a student is an auditory learner let's say, it's not like they won't benefit from the added clarity a picture or demonstration can bring. I also loved the new shepherd question you suggested to be used in the classroom. That will confuse students much less I think!
Hi Laura,
DeleteThank you for your feedback. I completely agree that a picture or demonstration would definitely benefit all students because it is always beneficial to see something, as opposed to just read or hear something. I would definitely show my students the finger counting, but I would have them count along with me, on their fingers. Thanks again for your comment!
Hi Jamie,
ReplyDeleteI think an overall theme for this week has been understanding in Math. I love how you focused on the types of questions asked. The Shepard problem is an excellent example of students not thinking or questioning before approaching a problem. This is not their fault because they have been taught to think that whatever "clues" are given in the problem will help them answer it. So, they are not taught to actually understand, reflect and work through it. This is something that we as future Math teachers have to strive to do for our students. Create a learning environment that encourages inquiry and questioning. Thanks for sharing!
Hi Jamie,
ReplyDeleteGreat post this week! I enjoyed reading about the importance of getting your students to understand math, instead of simply making them do it and moving on. It's silly that we expect our students every year to know the "knowledge" from last year...when what we have only taught them is a basic understanding, checked it off in the curriculum expectations, and then we moved on. Students have to fully understand how to do something, not just a simple generalization, or they end up forgetting everything they did, and wind up having to use their calculator to figure out Grade 2 math problems in their daily life (which is what I do haha). We definitely need to create a better environment for our students to learn, and what you said in your post is definitely a great start. Overall, amazing job! I look forward to reading your posts in the future!
- Elysse
Jamie,
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed reading your post this week. One, it was very well organized and simple to navigate. I really appreciated how at the end of your post you highlighted the main takeaways. Sometimes when reading you don't catch everything, providing a summary at the end just helps bring all the information together. Secondly, I thought it was great how you rewrote the "How Old is the Sheppard" problem, to one that would make more sense for students, and highlighting the importance of providing students with problem that they can solve. As math educators, we want all our students to be able to succeed, one way of making that possible is by choosing our questions carefully. We want to provide students questions that provide an entry point for all learners, is challenging, and allows them to demonstrate their learning. Thank you for the great post!